I have chanced upon a large collection of very old movies some of which I should have seen a long while ago but couldn’t because of inaccessibility. As much as I can, I will tell you my views on them, and the impact they had on me (for those that do make an impact, that is). The last week has been a tour of Guys and Dolls, a movie featuring Frank Sinatra and Marlon Brando (before he became the large framed guy we grew up knowing). The 1955 musical is famous for being the only movie in which the two famous men starred together, and the only one in which Marlon Brando sang. The story is nuanced and playful, but very entertaining, and timeless.
The other new memorable film I saw, also a musical, is The Fiddler on the Roof, a powerful story of family, love, tradition and the departure therefrom, and the story of the Jewish persecution in Tsarist Russia. I am always inevitably drawn to stories that have real life historical background because they constantly remind that we’re not just watching a movie, but learning from the story of a people that lived during a trying period in the larger history of the world. This story, based on the life of Tevye, a poor Jewish man with five daughters, is set in 1905 and tells of the endurance and transience of tradition, the strength of love’s bond, the perseverance of humanity in the face of persecution, the conviviality of family life, and the presence of hope in every dire situation. It was particularly interesting for me to discover that the persecution of Jews in Russia did not start during the Second World War but had been there far much earlier. And when you see a whole village trooping out on their feet in the cold winter out of a place where they’d lived for generations into the outside world to places unknown, your heart breaks. Add to this a letting go of a father of her daughter who had abandoned the faith and family tradition by marrying a Christian secretly, then you get a scene of denouement with a powerful emotional finish.
I can’t tell you more of any of them without letting out the plot, but I must strongly recommend them for whomever is interested in musicals, history, love, laughter and a few teardrops. You may also come off with a strong love for a few of the songs in The Fiddler on the Roof. My favourite is “Sunrise, Sunset.” and “If I were a rich man”, but you may also like “Tradition” and “Matchmaker.” As for Guys and Dolls, watch out for “Luck be a Lady” and a few other jazz classics.
Ten stars out of ten.
1
Abi Idowu at http://abidowu.vpweb.co.uk
I bought Fiddler on the Roof about 3 years ago because I somehow knew some of the songs without having ever watched the film. It was moving. Its among the films I sit and watch wwhen the world is quiet and I’m catching up with rest. Another favourite of mine is Moulin Rouge- I think the thought of an ashawo (pardon my crudeness) finding love just confirms the general human condition to me-All God’s babies want to be loved. Then The Producers. That’s one film I think I’ve watched as much as Sound of Music. It is so funny, just thinking of it makes me laugh.
Posted at September 6, 2010 on 4:01am.
2
Kola at http://www.ktravula.com
Thanks for the recommendation. I’ll definitely try to find those other ones you mentioned. I’ve found out that there are so many classics out there that I haven’t seen.
The Sound of Music, Mamma Mia and My Fair Lady are one of my best musicals. I can’t get enough of them or the songs. Mary Poppins is one of the ones always escaping my grip.
Posted at September 6, 2010 on 10:39am.
3
Clarissa at http://clarissasbox.blogspot.com
“Fiddler on the Roof” is based on the writings of the famous Jewish writer Sholom Aleikhem. I love this writer and it kills me to see how his beautiful works were killed by this cheesy music and the idiotic musical format.
If you haven’t been able to guess yet, I hate musicals. 🙂 🙂 My friends forced me to watch “The Sound of Music” once and I still have nightmares that I have to watch this aesthetically horryfing, inane thing with ugly actors and annoying children once again.
As for the Jews in Russia, in the Russian Empire there was a pale of settlement for the Jews which they were not a llowed to leave. The tsarist government supported pogroms and muders of Jewish people all the time. That’s why the Jews wholeheartedly supported the revolution.
Posted at September 6, 2010 on 1:07pm.
4
Kola at http://www.ktravula.com
You hate movies. You hate musicals. Sigh sigh. I’ve run out of recommendations for you. One of the reasons why I tend to like to read books first if they exist before seeing the movie is this same sense of disappointment I might get if it’s not properly done. The bright side is that I never bothered to read any of these books before seeing the movie, so I guess I can only be impressed when I finally do read them. However, these musicals are top notch and I’ll hate for you to miss out on the pleasure in them 🙂 :). Come on!
What I don’t understand about the Russian revolution then is why the Communist government eventually turned against the Jews again before and during the World War II. If they helped them in the earlier revolution, one would expect that they would get some protection from the government against external aggression, this time from Germany. What went wrong?
Posted at September 6, 2010 on 10:28pm.
5
Clarissa at http://clarissasbox.blogspot.com
I told you, I’m a very limited human being, what can I do? 🙂 🙂
As for the Jews in the Soviet Union, there were two major reasons they suddenly started to get persecuted in the Soviet Union around 1949 or so:
1. After the war, the country lay in ruins. Many soldiers were coming back from Europe telling their families that even devastated by the World War Europe had a much higher level of well-being than the USSR. The country was so closed before, that people had no idea. There was a lot of popular resentment, so Stalin had to channel this anger against somebody. And who better than the Jews?
2. There is overwhelming evidence that in the last years of his life Stalin was preparing for World War III. He couldn’t start it himself because that wouldn’t look good. So he had to provoke the US to attack first. His plan to deport every single Jew in the Soviet Union to Siberia was very likely to make the US too angry to sit by.
Posted at September 7, 2010 on 11:19pm.